Showing posts with label Government. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Government. Show all posts

Saturday, February 23, 2008

FTC Identity Theft Data Causes Skewed Views

The FTC has issued the latest report for 2007 on Consumer Fraud and Identity Theft Complaint Data. With no great shock or surprise identity theft is still the number one complaint by a long shot being 32% of the reported 813,899 total complaints reported. The next closest category was Shop at Home/ Catalog Sales with a mere 8%. There were 20 categories in all and the bottom 13 categories were each 2% or less.

This is a good report as it paints many pictures but at the same time skews the reality due to how the information is collected.

Certain areas of the US have more information available to consumers or police agencies that promote reporting identity theft to the FTC.

Because the reporting is entirely voluntary lends more of an explanation as to why some states have more incidences than others. The reality of identity theft crime statistics goes much deeper than the simplistic overview of the charts of this report.

A Skewed View

I have read a number of articles from various states that have had a decrease in the number of incidences reported to the FTC are feeling incredibly good about it. They are utilizing this information to pat themselves on the back. In Wisconsin one state that experiinced a decrease, had the administrator of the Division of Trade and Consumer Protection claiming they like to think they are getting the word out better, but also claims she does not know why they ended up so low in the rankings. She obviously needs to take a class on Understanding Reports 101, or is just looking to get a promotion. Statements like this coming from someone who is the head of consumer protection for the state should be a bit unnerving for the residents of Wisconsin.

But kudos goes to the Wisconsin Bankers Association who says the FTC information does not reflect what they are seeing.

Take a state such as Colorado with this same view. They have 4 of the top 50 metropolitan areas in the US reporting identity theft. Of those 4 areas, they all had a highly disproportionate number of reports compared to the other 46 areas. That does not directly indicate it is a state with an unusually high rate of identity theft, but likely a state that is actually educating consumers on what to do and encouraging reporting to the FTC.

No signs of abatement

One thing can be said with certainty is that identity theft is not showing any significant signs of abatement.

With all of the services available to stop this, and alert you of that, and the thousands that are paying monthly fees, one would expect this number would be dropping dramatically, or at least see a slight dent in the numbers.

But then again if you rely on some reporting agency with a subscription service you pay monthly to tell you someone has your information and tried to open some type of account in your name, the theft has already happened and is likely eligible to be reported to the FTC anyway. Paying money each month to have someone tell you a theft has occurred will not change the fact that a thief already has your information.

Reporting to the Police

What is still shocking in this report is the number of people who did not report the crime to a police agency which was 65% or 158,535. Why they chose not to is a mystery that we are looking into, but even more disturbing was the revelation that of the 35% that did take the time to report the crime 8% of those did not get a report taken from the police.

The reality of what was going on at the time is the police are looking around the precinct when a victim calls or shows up. They see they have 2 muggers, a car thief, and an arsonist all waiting to be booked and processed. An identity theft victim comes in declaring a theft that by appearances likely occurred across state lines or out of the country. The probability of an arrest is remote, but the headache of the extra paperwork 100% guaranteed.

The message sent is this is a crime to be treated lightly by consumers and the some (not all) police agencies are not be doing enough to encourage or educate people in how to protect themselves. If thousands are turned away and led to believe the police can do nothing, then a feeling of helplessness will likely prevail.

The best defense is self defense. A majority of identity theft starts with people leaving the gates to their identity open and allowing the fraud to occur.

Wednesday, February 6, 2008

Is your W-2 missing from your mailbox this week?

This really is about the golden ticket for an ID thief, your W-2. It has everything they need to get started being you. That form is your link between your employer, you, and the federal government. It is the one item in your mailbox this time of year that the thieves know is coming and has your vital social security number on it.

The beauty of that golden ticket is they are sitting in millions of mailboxes this week waiting for you to save it from the grasp of an identity thief. Didn’t get yours yet? Did your employer mail it out already to an unlocked curbside ID thief treasure chest, also known as a mailbox? You might want to start inquiring now.

What makes this so easy for the thieves is you have been receiving it in this manner forever and it has never been a problem. You know it is coming; you wait for it almost, especially if you are anticipating a refund. Many also know that their employer is required to issue them no latter that the last day of January. For those who choose not to hand it directly to the employees, they use the always reliable, United States Postal Service.

The safety net ends there. Once it is placed in that old trusted receptacle on your house, by the curb, at the end of a long driveway, or in a communal type apartment system, it is fair game to anyone who happens by.

That’s what makes you so vulnerable. An old system that seemed stable and reliable is now being exploited on a grand scale by identity thieves who rely on you to think that it will not happen. Ask 1 out of every 30 Americans last year who thought the same way. They will beg to differ.

Wednesday, July 25, 2007

Can Past Lessons Offer Clues to Combating Identity Theft?

In 1994 about 58 percent of the US population was buckling up. By mid 2006 approximately 81% of the US population buckled up. Why the dramatic change? Did everyone suddenly recognize that the seatbelts they had been ignoring for years were suddenly cool? No, the reality came partially with education campaigns and laws enacted by many states in the 80’s that forced or convinced people to buckle up.

Today, the generation who never or barely used seat belts is giving way to a generation who has always used them. Part education, part learned behavior, but regardless the effort has paid off immensely. There are thousands alive today that would not be, if this effort had not been undertaken by numerous agencies, both public and private. Local television news channels tout that drivers of horrific looking accidents survived because they were buckled in. All of this adds to awareness and the effort has made seatbelt use the norm not the exception.

So how well is education and enforcement working? The latest numbers available from the US Department of Transportation shows an increase in drivers, miles driven, and number of registered cars on the road. But the fatalities per number of licensed drivers, per miles driven, and per registered vehicles, have been steadily dropping since 1994. The statistics from the NHTSA from 1986-1999 have clearly demonstrated an absolute link to the reduction in fatalities from seatbelt use.

This proves that the plan of educating and enforcement has worked and continues to work up to this day, but shockingly 19%, or 1 out of 5 still don’t think they need this life saving device. They live in the world of “it will never happen to me”, or “it only happens to other people”. Yet, every 13 minutes there is a vehicle fatality and of those some deaths could be avoided with a seatbelt if the person had only believed or understood.

How this is similar to identity theft is when it comes to our identities many are living in the same world of “it will never happen to me”, or “it only happens to other people”. There are many simple but effective changes people can initiate to stop identity theft from happening but choose not to. There are preventative measures they can put in place to mitigate it, but the majority will sit and wait for something to happen before they react.

As with seat belts, only until people become educated will they take the steps to prevent an event from occurring. Many still refuse to embrace technology to reduce risk, and instead they avoid or ignore it.

Over time, thousands lost lives while sitting on the simplistic technology of an unused seat belt. Will consumers finally step up to the plate and take simple but effective pro-active steps to prevent identity theft, or will they continue to ride around unbuckled and hope an accident never occurs? Every 21 seconds there are 3 new identity theft victims, of which 2 were potentially preventable by the victim.

Abatement of identity theft will start to change significantly once individuals start to take control of their personal behavior and not rely on others or hoping nothing will happen to them. Recognizing the vulnerabilities in personal everyday habits and making changes will reduce your risk significantly.

Many are already recognizing that they need to do something, and the actions of those will undoubtedly start a trend. But for those who are unsure of what to do, and still do nothing, are likely to become tomorrow’s victims.

Hopefully it doesn’t take 15 years for 80% of the population to finally become educated on how to adequately protect their identity.

Monday, July 9, 2007

GAO Reports on Identity Theft, Sort of

Recently the US Government Accountability Office released its findings of a study on the net effect of data breaches, stolen data, and unaccounted for data and how much actual identity theft resulted from such occurrences. They undertook this task to help Congress decide if a federal law should be considered for a national breach notification requirement. Some states already have laws in effect to various degrees requiring notification of data lost so that consumers can take immediate actions to see if they’ve become a victim.

Sounds a bit odd, but breach notification would most likely just give you a heads up a bit sooner if you are a victim. Many times a data breach notification is the first time a victim looks at a bank or credit card statement, balances a checkbook for the first time in ten years, or obtains a credit report.

The GAO was asked to examine three distinct areas

(1) The incidence and circumstances of breaches of sensitive personal information

(2) The extent to which such breaches have resulted in identity theft

(3) The potential benefits, costs, and challenges associated with breach notification requirements.

The GAO used various sources for the research and came up with an earth shattering discovery; data thefts are rampant and occur frequently and are probably underreported due to lack of voluntary or mandatory disclosure.

They also determined they can’t directly link identity theft to many of the data thefts they reviewed because there is not clear and conclusive evidence that directly links those breaches with identity theft. Apparently the identity thieves are not disclosing the abundant sources of their windfall.

There you have it, if it is not conclusive then it must not have occurred, or at least they can’t say it occurred. It does not mean that it didn’t.

They even admitted that the lack of reporting on the part of victims also leads to skewed and invalid data that cannot be used to create a valid statistical picture.

So how do many interpret this : “GAO finds little identity theft results from data breaches”.

Apparently there are a lot of thieves going to a lot of trouble stealing personal data, then changing their minds finding religion and doing nothing with it after all.

But if that is the case, then where did all that personal stolen information come from that results in the billions of dollars in personal losses from the millions of actual victims each year? There was not a place to include them in this report.

Monday, May 14, 2007

The Hidden Costs of Identity Theft

Recently I read a news article written about a seminar recently given on identity theft by an attorney from the Federal Trade Commission. While I will save my opinion of his stated facts about the cost of identity theft for another post, he said 99 percent of identity theft victims pay nothing, and if there is any cost vendors pay for it! WHAT? Did he just fall out of the sky and crash land on planet earth, head first?

Just think about all the other costs, the unseen, uncalculated, or unaccounted costs, we could be referring to a value that in some instances would be unbelievable.

Let’s look at time alone. Depending on what statistical survey you refer to, the time spent per victim usually averages in the range of 500 hours to clear all the hurdles to restore their name and credit and obtain any restitution. When do they do this? Many during normal business hours. An employer of a victim, and many are employed, will lose thousands in lost time and productivity due to phone calls, paperwork, making copies, faxing information and police reports. Also time off for trips to court, an attorney’s office, or police department. Think of the time loss and cost to the self employed.

Emotional costs are also not included in his figure. I was at an event recently and spoke with many individuals about identity theft, and I was truly amazed at how many had been victims or knew a victim directly. One woman had the most emotionally charged story about a close relative who stole her identity. She was forced to press police charges against that close relative, otherwise she could not get the $6,000 in theft cleared from her name and she did not have the funds to cover it either. She was extremely distraught because she knew the negative impact it would have on her if she did not press charges, but she also knew the lifelong damage the close relative would endure for this one event.

Others feel violated, hurt, constantly suspicious, untrusting and the list goes on.

So what impact do those feelings that now have on the economy? Many of these people will stop using credit or debit cards, will not buy online, will not do many things that will impact the economy much like a recession.

And for the cost to the vendors that do actually pay for or cover losses, where does he think that money will ultimately come from? We all bear the burden of paying for the costs of identity theft. Much in the same manner we share the costs for insurance when a major hurricane hits even a majority were never impacted by it.

So in the grand scheme of identity theft the impact of the actual dollar amount may only be a small part of the total cost, but everyone who gets hit with identity theft pays a price.

Thursday, May 10, 2007

Homeland Security Department Not So Secure

Last week the Transportation Security Administration had lost a computer hard drive containing data and payroll information for about 100,000 employee records. They use the term lost, but seeing who is involved in looking for it, stolen is probably the better word choice. They may find it being used as a bookend somewhere.

The data was on employees who worked at the agency between January 2002 and August 2005 and included Social Security and bank account numbers, names, dates of birth, salaries, benefit deductions, and bank routing information.

In case you don’t recall, the TSA is a part of the Homeland Security Department. That does not sound reassuring at all. The agency that was chartered after 911 to protect us is not even protecting itself.

But if you look at a short chronology from the last 3 weeks you could not make up this entire string of events that has just rolled out of our elected government.

- April 23, 2007 The President’s Identity Theft Task Force – Combating Identity Theft a Strategic Plan – 120 pages of what Washington wants everyone to do

- April 2007 Government Accountability Office – Privacy – Lessons Learned about Data Breach Notification – 78 pages of how and when to notify people the next time it happens! They were planning on it!

- May 4, 2007 TSA notifies 100,000 of a lost hard drive

- May 9, 2007 The American Federation of Government Employees (AFGE), along with four security screeners, charged that the TSA had recklessly violated the Privacy Act and also violated the Aviation and Transportation Security Act. The class action suit was filed in U.S. District Court in Washington on Wednesday 5/9/07.

President Bush has to be in the White House banging his head on the oval office walls. He would ask Attorney General Gonzales, but he has his own issues to worry about, and he issued that 120 page report, so he’s off the hook. So who else can take responsibility for this? Typical reaction is to roll a head or two in the management ranks. What does that solve? It only keeps the same inept individuals still guarding the data, which they didn’t do so well to start with.

What really needs to happen is people who are truly responsible for this, at the office level, get fired, loose their pensions drain their 401’s. If you were handed information and told your financial future depended on keeping it safe, you can be sure there would be people keeping better track of that data better than their wallet.

Lack of accountability breeds lack of responsibility.

Thursday, May 3, 2007

President’s Identity Theft Task Force

Last week Washington released a 120 page manifesto about all the ways identity theft is affecting all of us. A little late to the table? The Bush administration made mention of it briefly in 2003 and I believe they became preoccupied with a bigger fish called Saddam.

Well now that he’s fertilizer, they can get back to what’s on the minds of the American people. So it took them four years, and significant year over year increases in this crime ever since, for them to return to the topic.

This action is a result in the uproar being made by the public and this being covered by media all of the time, especially when a major data breach occurs.

Lost in all this public reaction is the fact that people are still engaging in high risk behavior when it comes to protecting their identity, and many still feel it will never happen to them. No amount of legislation will help them until people start helping themselves. At the end of the day the best defense is self defense.

We can’t expect the government to stop all of the gaps so we can continue as in the past leaving ourselves wide open. They can only protect you so much, the rest is up to you. You must realize that it is individuals (not the government or businesses) who will lose the most and suffer the biggest hardships financially and emotionally from this type of crime.


If Identity Theft continues to grow, as it has in the past few years, it will eventually start to have a major economic impact and the federal government is foreseeing this as very real possibility in the very near future. Statistically we all stand a good chance of getting impacted by identity theft; it will be the ones who have built up the best defense who will be impacted the least.

Don’t wait for it to happen to you!